Re: [-empyre-] meat and potatoes space

[alexkillough <alexkillough@gmail.com>]

Maybe it is progress-
So Lets play.


Man, looking back at the original questions below, it seems as though 
the current topic goes right along with the matter at hand. I think I 
addressed many of your ?s from my own regional/cultural/social place, 
and it seems as though Robby has dealt with said in his questioning 
also.

 I am not sure we have broken so far from the discourse.... And no one 
said we all agree, but maybe were trying to clarify individual points 
of view in a manner which is illuminative but so as not to bash or 
flame. This seems to be one metric of making collective network 
endeavors (moderately) successful: stepping back and 
reconsidering/rehashing/redefining.  And then remaking. Better than 
arguing and destroying I think...

This conversation and the topics at hand this month have been of 
particular interest, and I really appreciate the moderators, guests, 
and other contributors continuing to fill my inbox with more 
information than I will be able to properly digest for a good while. So 
with that we can all continue to create, consider, create...(flame, 
bash, argue, create)

So Lets play.

I. Questions- of Precepts...
	1. Who are we when we think of a network of spaces?
	2. Who are we (this is a super-fucking-inclussive we... I want to be a 
part of any club that will 	have me and want anyone to be a member of 
my club as long as they are members a club that is 	meaningful.)
	3. What is OUR common denomonators
 	 a. what values do we share
 	 b. what ideals
 	 c. what goals
 	 d. what resources
	4. What are our differences?
	5. Who are we in our local cities and scenes and how does this relate 
to our more global we?
	6. How do we distinguish ourselves from the those that are clearly not 
us?


On Nov 29, 2005, at 10:35 PM, marc wrote:

> For me, this thread is a great snap-shot of our current moment and a 
> weakness of our collective  discursive practice.
>
> We all agree in the end! And that is all we learn!
> Where has this conversation gone?
>
> This is the atomization of our intellectual heritage and future so 
> that we have no agenda besides stating our opinion.
>
> Christina and I set out an agenda in week one, and I set out an 
> outline entitled "play ball" inviting collective engagement towards 
> progressive problem solving.
>
> Weeks later, we are bickering (me included) about things that seem 
> like we can all somewhat agree upon.
>
>
> Sad.
>
> Marc
>
>
>
>
> On Nov 29, 2005, at 9:23 PM, Ryan Griffis wrote:
>
> > On Nov 29, 2005, at 7:00 PM, marc wrote:
> > > I would imagine that we could collectively imagine that there is a
> > > hybrid practices between the web and the "meat-world" (great term). 
> > > And
> > > that we could collectively allow for a functionality on both
> > > extremes...
> >
> > i think Robby's post is meant to be a bit (or more) provocative here 
> > (of course, i've been known to be wrong!). and his crit of tech lines 
> > up with some of the other concerns about the false promises of IT to 
> > deliver democracy, so it's not without some sound foundation. Read 
> > Hakim Bey (aka Peter Lamborn Wilson) lately?
> > Trebor text posted earlier i think also asks some great questions 
> > that had a couple people on his New Media Education challenging the 
> > effectiveness of  IT for the purposes of the left.
> > http://mailman.thing.net/pipermail/idc/2005-November/000089.html
> > Anyway, i think the whole dichotomy thing IT/anti-IT is kind of a 
> > distraction and a bit of a red herring... were people arguing over 
> > whether or not the printing press was going to change the world for 
> > the better, lift up the oppressed, just by being produced?
> > it did no doubt change the world, but it certainly didn't eliminate 
> > oppression, as our reality testifies to.
> > great posts.
> > ryan
> >
> > _______________________________________________
> > empyre forum
> > empyre@lists.cofa.unsw.edu.au
> > http://www.subtle.net/empyre
>
> _______________________________________________
> empyre forum
> empyre@lists.cofa.unsw.edu.au
> http://www.subtle.net/empyre